Unsolved
This post is more than 5 years old
5.8K Posts
0
33847
Avast!'s and Panda's EULAs
It has been a while since I scrutinized The EULA of any AV I've used, but I've seen some chatter
that avast! has been spying on customers. So I've appended some excerpts from their current EULA,
and leave it to others to figure out what it permits them to do:
AVAST END USER LICENSE AGREEMENT
(FREE VERSION)
... 8. Privacy; processing of personal information
The Software collects certain information, which may include personally identifiable information,
from the computer on which it is installed, including:
8.1 URLs of any websites you have visited;
8.6 Certain information about your computer hardware, software and/or network connection;
AVAST may publish or share such information with third
parties that are not part of the AVAST Group but will only ever do so after removing personally
identifiable information.
The collected information may be transferred to third parties or to other countries that may have less
protective data protection laws than the country or region in which you are situated (including the
European Union). AVAST takes measures to ensure that any collected information will receive an
adequate level of protection if and when transferred. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this
Agreement or any Documentation or other materials provided to you in connection with the Software,
AVAST reserves all rights to cooperate with any legal process or government inquiry (including, but
not limited to, court orders and law enforcement requests) related to your use of the Software. In
connection with such cooperation, AVAST may provide documents and information relevant to a
court subpoena or government or other legal investigation, which may include disclosure of your
personally identifiable information.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the AVAST privacy policy, you consent during the term of this Agreement and for one (1) year thereafter to (i) AVAST sharing information collected by you during your purchase, installation or registration of the Software with AVAST’s distributors and other business partners and (ii) use of such information by AVAST, its distributors and other business partners to present you with information that may be relevant to you, including offers of software, services or other products.
http://files.avast.com/files/legal/eula-avast-free-2015.pdf
[emphasis added]
Panda's AV EULA is a bit more problematic, in that I was referred to a legal document on their website,
written in Spanish. I might have to enlist Hernan to interpret. However the part I see written in
English says:
... for the purpose of contracting and using the program, the licensee may have to give PANDA certain
personal data. The licensee is hereby informed and gives consent to the processing of his/her personal
data, which is facilitated to PANDA as a consequence of the contracting and use of the program, in
order to access information or services provided by PANDA or to maintain the contractual relationship
or to send marketing information by any means including electronically. PANDA informs the licensee
that it will treat such personal data in accordance with current applicable legislation and as established
in its Privacy Policy. The licensee can access the Privacy Policy at:
http://www.pandasecurity.com/spain/enterprise/media/legal-notice/#e10
(This last link takes me to a Spanish language website - Panda is based in Spain - sneaky!)
I have no reason to believe that paid AVs use privacy policies that are any better.
dalem29
2 Intern
2 Intern
•
2.2K Posts
0
October 24th, 2014 08:00
I think they are saying in a legalistic way that they are, indeed, selling your personal and browsing information to the highest bidders! :emotion-6:
ky331
3 Apprentice
3 Apprentice
•
15.3K Posts
0
October 24th, 2014 12:00
Avast's official response
https://forum.avast.com/?topic=157693.msg1140066#msg1140066
joe53
5.8K Posts
0
October 24th, 2014 19:00
When I started this thread, I specifically didn't link or refer to that howtogeek article. I didn't find it well written, and it seemed like a rant. It is not a site I frequent, nor am familiar with. It did however spur me to do a bit of research.
I haven't used avast! in a couple of years, but certainly do not recall seeing any of the advertising graphics pictured in the article. Then again, I have most cookies blocked, and seldom get any ads in any of my browsers. I did not wish to adress the specific issues raised in that article, but would note that what few ads I receive do not seem to be targeted at me based on previous searches. And I certainly did not switch to Panda because of any ads or search results related to avast!
But I thought it would be timely to review the Privacy Policies of both avast! and Panda Free AVs for comparison, to generate some discussion. Frankly, I was disappointed with both EULAs. The "notwithstanding" clause from avast! was just obscure legalese, which seems to contradict previous clauses to let them share info with whomever they want, and Panda choses to hide its Policy with Spanish.
I tend to agree with Dale, and always assume that when I register and provide personal info to any vendor, at least some of that info is collected and made available to "business partners" and "third parties" for marketing purposes. All I can do to mitigate this is to configure my cookie policies in a given browser (especially blocking 3rd party cookies), use a junk email account, never give my real name, and to use a good ad-blocker.
iroc9555
1K Posts
0
October 25th, 2014 18:00
Hi Joe.
I am finally in. Thanks to Stacy and Robert. Also to ky331 who contacted Robert.
About the Panda EULA. To tell you the truth it does not sound like an EULA because it does not talk about the program but the site, and what it might collect by the used of cookies. There is a small paragraph where Panda security is named, but I do not know if it is reffering to the program.
Now, it explicitly says that private information of the user can be shared with other Panda Security stablisments around the world and resellers; However, it also says it is done accordingly with some law in thier organic civil code and internacional agreements to protect the privacy of the users.
I think all this mess, like you said, it is just ranting. Which program does not collect info ? Which site does not collect info ? What they do with it ? Well, I believe there are laws about it. Aren't there ?
A big company like Avast, Panda, Google, Facebook, even a site like How To Geek if they share or sell the info they collect without sanitize it ( with private info about the users ) have a lot to lose. I have seen it latetly visiting sites where there is a warning that they use cookies to see what one is doing and if one does not want to agree to it the site does not work. Others sites just warn you and it is one decision to continue or not. Also you see it more and more when installing programs ( Like Avast ) beside the EULA you get another window warning you so there is nothing sneaky about it.
joe53
5.8K Posts
0
October 25th, 2014 20:00
Thanks Hernan for the Panda info.
I figured you must have been having login problems. Good to see you are back.
Obviously all downloaded software and website registrations require collection of some personal info. What is done with this info is anyone's guess these days. The EULAs have become too obscure to determine what the privacy policies really allow. The days when these policies would simply say "we will not share your personal info with anyone"are gone, it seems. Now we get confusing subordinate clauses, and 5 page EULAs that would require a lawyer to interpret.
All I can say is that in all the years I used avast! and Panda, I never was targeted by adware.
ky331
3 Apprentice
3 Apprentice
•
15.3K Posts
0
October 26th, 2014 05:00
Welcome Back, Hernan... great to see you again :emotion-2:
EULAs have become a joke, as it's generally acknowledged that most users don't bother to read them at all. Let's face it: if you really want that program... especially if it's a paid one and you've already bought it... you have little (practical) choice other than to accept its EULA.
Whether actually true or just an "urban legend", there's the classic story about a EULA including a clause "agreeing to give up your first-born son to the software's authors"... likely a test to see if ANYONE bothered to read it :emotion-4:
iroc9555
1K Posts
0
October 26th, 2014 09:00
Thanks. Thanks to everyone.
Indeed. I am an Avast user at heart. Although I have tried other AV like Norton, McAfee, Panda, and AVG, I always return to Avast, and may be I should not say this but look at the warning windows Avast displays. It says " We promise". It is a joke. It should say " We agree or abide". It sounds like a little boy promising his parents he will be a good.
Also true. What else can you do after buying the program. Ask for refund ? It is sometimes time consuming and frustating procedure.