Unsolved

This post is more than 5 years old

2 Posts

4437

January 23rd, 2005 18:00

CRT OR LCD ?

I am thinking of getting a new computer and monitor but i cannot settle on which type of monitor to get i play a lot of games and movies on my computers and i want something that will give me excellent picture quality i currently have a 19 crt monitor but i lcd's look very attractive. I would be grateful for any advice anyone could give me

28 Posts

January 24th, 2005 03:00

Hey ED1962,

If you are a serious gamer and desktop space is not an issue, than I would go with a CRT monitor.  Until recently I have been using a CRT for many years and most of my time is done playing games.  I just got a new Dell system, ordered it in early December, and one of the upgrades was a free flat panel.  I was excited as it was going to be my first LCD display.  It was the Dell Ultrasharp 1905FP. I thought this was going to be an excellent monitor, until I started looking through these Dell Forums.  When my computer arrived I set it up and was amazed at the quality of the picture.  Then I decided to install and play the three games I received as gifts: Farcry, Doom 3, and Half Life 2.  The ghosting on the 1905FP was horrible!  I also noticed some ghosting while playing DVDs and watching TV, as I got a computer with Media Center.  I got a replacement monitor from Dell and it was even worse than the first.  So I did some more digging through the forums and found that people were, overall, pleased with the 2001FP.  Since it has a faster response time, 16ms as compared to the 20ms on the 1905FP, I hope to not experience the same problems.  Like I said, desktop space is an issue with me and the initial picture quality of the LCD was amazing so I am going to try the 2001FP.  I should receive the monitor this week so I will let you know if it works out alright.  If it doesn't than I am going to return it, and buy a bigger desk that can house a 20+ inch CRT.  Be warned though, the 1905FP is a horrible monitor so definitely stay away from that one.  The Tech. Support at Dell has even confirmed that they are flawed.  I have gathered that a CRT is, as of now, the best for gamers, until they get the response times down on the LCDs.

Jon

Dell Dimension 8400
Media Center Edition
P4 3.4 Ghz HT w/ 800 Mhz FSB
Dell 2001FP LCD
2 GB DC DDR2 SDRAM @ 533 Mhz
256 MB PCIe Nvidia Geforce 6800
250 GB SATA HD
DVD-ROM + DVD+/-RW dbl layer
SB Live 24bit AHD
Dell 5650 5.1
TV Tuner and more

2 Posts

January 24th, 2005 21:00

Jon thanks for repling to my question you have helped me out very much i hope you get your monitor problems taken care of soon also.
thanks again for the help
ED

28 Posts

January 24th, 2005 22:00

I wouldn't totally discredit an LCD display though.  Hopefully more people will reply and tell you the success that they have had with their LCD displays.  I will let you know how the 2001FP does as well.
 
Jon
 
Dell Dimension 8400
Media Center Edition
P4 3.4 Ghz HT w/ 800 Mhz FSB
Dell 2001FP LCD
2 GB DC DDR2 SDRAM @ 533 Mhz
256 MB PCIe Nvidia Geforce 6800
250 GB SATA HD
DVD-ROM + DVD+/-RW dbl layer
SB Live 24bit AHD
Dell 5650 5.1
TV Tuner and more
No Events found!

Top