Start a Conversation

Solved!

Go to Solution

2514

February 9th, 2022 12:00

LACP on S4048-ON with 2x S5248F-ON not working

We got two new S5248F-ON which I configured with VLT. I connected lots of compute nodes with LACP to the new switches, all working fine. But I've been trying all day to connect our S4048-ON using 2x 40GBit cables and cannot get this to work. At first I thought it was STP interfering, but even with STP disabled, no LACP.

The 5248s report all ok:
EthSW25G-1# show interface port-channel 55 summary  
LAG     Mode      Status    Uptime              Ports
55      L2-HYBRID up        01:18:35            Eth 1/1/55:1 (Up)

But the 4048 shows no ports:
EthSW10G(conf)#do show interfaces port-channel 55 brief  
   LAG  Mode  Status       Uptime      Ports           
L   55   L2    down         00:00:00    

But these ports  are configured:
interface fortyGigE 1/50
no ip address
!   
port-channel-protocol LACP  
 port-channel 55 mode passive  
no shutdown
!
interface fortyGigE 1/51
no ip address
!   
port-channel-protocol LACP  
 port-channel 55 mode passive  
no shutdown
!

I tried active and passive, no change. All physical interfaces are no shut, lines are up:

EthSW10G(conf)#do show interfaces fortyGigE 1/50
fortyGigE 1/50 is up, line protocol is up


EthSW10G(conf)#do show interfaces fortyGigE 1/51
fortyGigE 1/51 is up, line protocol is up

But the LAG is down:
EthSW10G(conf)#do show interfaces port-channel 55
Port-channel 55 is up, line protocol is down(minimum links not up)
Created by LACP protocol

The 5248 have the latest OS10 10.5.3.2 installed, I updated the 4048 to OS9 9.14(2.11) today.

What am I missing? Is LACP not possible in this setup? 

BTW: When I configure the switches to not use LACP, so just use the cables directly, it works fine. I am not sure if this is a good setup for production though (if one link goes down: packet loss)

I'd be really grateful for any kind of hint why this is not working...

 

3 Posts

February 15th, 2022 01:00

Just to finish this topic: I don't exactly know why the configuration suddenly worked, but it does now and it is stable. Maybe the switches just needed a small kick...

3 Posts

February 9th, 2022 14:00

Update:

I changed the mode on the S5248Fs to 'passive' and on the S4048 to 'active' and suddenly the port channel came online:

EthSW10G(conf-if-range-fo-1/50-1/51)#do show interfaces port-channel 55 brief
Codes: L - LACP Port-channel
      O - OpenFlow Controller Port-channel
      A - Auto Port-channel
      I - Internally Lagged

   LAG  Mode  Status       Uptime      Ports           
L   55   L2    up           00:07:53    Fo 1/50    (Up)
                                       Fo 1/51    (Up)


Afterwards, I could change the mode back to 'active' everywhere and it now stays online. Is this a firmware bug?

But it seems there are still problems, not every node (on different switches) can ping each other...

 

Moderator

 • 

4.1K Posts

February 9th, 2022 21:00

Hi, from what I see, this a software issues. Please upgrade to the latest.  All the interfaces will need to be shutdown at one point.

 

https://dell.to/33bqM3d How to create Link Aggregation Groups (LAGs) on Dell Networking EMC OS9 Switches | Dell US

https://dell.to/339RGs3

Dell EMC Networking OS9 How to Troubleshoot Creating a Port Channel (LAG) - Link Aggregation | Dell US

 

Please note that when creating port-channel between two switches you need to follow the sequential procedure.

No Events found!

Top